Migraines: Why Some Patients Suffer Far More Than Others

Man with headache holding a glass of water
Photo: fizkes / Shutterstock

Migraine is not just a bad headache. For millions of Americans, it is a disease that steals workdays, family time, and basic function, and one of the nation’s top headache doctors wants that fact taken seriously.

Quick Take

  • Dr. Todd Schwedt, president of the American Headache Society, says migraine is “incredibly disabling” and remains widely underdiagnosed.
  • A U.S. systematic review found 42.4% of migraine patients had moderate-to-severe disability by 2018, up sharply from 22% in 2005.
  • A Mayo Clinic diary study found chronic migraine patients stay impaired even between attacks, not just during them.
  • Global data show migraine causes nearly 10% of years lived with disability among women ages 15 to 49.

A Leading Headache Doctor Puts a Number on the Pain

Dr. Todd Schwedt leads Mayo Clinic’s Neuroimaging of Headache Disorders Laboratory and serves as president of the American Headache Society. He has called migraine “a leading cause of disability among women under the age of 50.” He also said the disease is “frequently underdiagnosed and undertreated,” a warning aimed at patients who shrug off symptoms and doctors who miss them.

Schwedt’s comments line up with a position statement from the American Headache Society. That statement reports migraine accounts for about 9.8% of years lived with disability among girls and women ages 15 to 49. It also links the disease to missed work, missed school, lower productivity, and pulling away from family and friends.

The Numbers Behind the Claim

A 2024 systematic review backs up the disability claim with hard data. Researchers tracked 26 studies using the Migraine Disability Assessment Scale, a tool that measures lost days at work, home, and in social life. Moderate-to-severe disability among migraine patients jumped from 22% in 2005 to 42.4% by 2018, nearly doubling in just over a decade.

A separate study coauthored by Schwedt dug into chronic migraine patients using daily diaries. On days with moderate-to-severe headache, physical impairment scores averaged 41.5 on a standard scale. Even on headache-free days, scores still averaged 5.2, showing that impairment can linger after the pain itself fades.

Light sensitivity adds another layer. Schwedt told Mayo Clinic News Network that normal lighting during an attack can cause real visual discomfort and make the headache worse. That often forces patients to retreat into a dark room just to function, cutting them off from work and family in the moment they need support most.

Why Some Patients Suffer Far More Than Others

Not every migraine patient faces the same burden. The global My Migraine Voice survey focused on people with frequent migraine whose preventive treatments had already failed. Among that group, 49% felt limited in daily life during every phase of an attack, and 87% reported it hurt their work, home, or social life. Nearly four in ten had visited an emergency room in the past year, and 23% had been hospitalized overnight.

That survey describes a high-burden group, not every migraine sufferer in America. Episodic migraine, chronic migraine, and treatment-resistant migraine are different conditions with different outcomes. Lumping them together risks making mild cases sound as severe as the toughest ones, or missing just how bad the hardest cases truly are.

Underdiagnosis Keeps the Problem Hidden

Schwedt’s warning about underdiagnosis matters because migraine often hides in plain sight. Patients without visible injuries or scars can still lose entire days to pain, light sensitivity, and nausea, yet employers and even family members may not grasp the toll. When fewer people get diagnosed and treated, the disease’s true reach stays undercounted in official data and public conversation alike.

The research is clear that migraine drives real, measurable disability for a large share of patients, especially women under 50 and those with frequent, treatment-resistant attacks. The exact severity depends on which patients and which measuring stick you use. But the core message from Schwedt and the data he cites holds up: migraine is not a minor inconvenience. It is a serious disease that deserves serious medical attention, not a shrug and an aspirin.

Sources:

youtube.com, e-hpr.org, report.nih.gov, ncbi.nlm.nih.gov